INFP vs INTP

Introspective and Pragmatic: ENTJ, INTJ, ENTP, INTP

INFP vs INTP

Postby mserogerb » Sun Feb 13, 2011 6:25 pm

I have a friend/relative that sometimes tests as an INFP but lately has been testing as INTP.
The IN P are all very strong but the T/F is weak. So he finds that some of the INTP profile fits and some does not and some of the INFP profile fits and some does not.

Have any of you experienced this in yourself or others?

mserogerb
mserogerb
 
Posts: 83
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2010 8:47 pm
MBTI Type: ENTJ
Gender: Male

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby BlackBriar » Mon Feb 14, 2011 5:31 am

mserogerb wrote:I have a friend/relative that sometimes tests as an INFP but lately has been testing as INTP.
The IN P are all very strong but the T/F is weak. So he finds that some of the INTP profile fits and some does not and some of the INFP profile fits and some does not.

Have any of you experienced this in yourself or others?

mserogerb



analyse their hobbies and their decision making styles as well.
BlackBriar
 
Posts: 74
Joined: Tue Jul 06, 2010 3:30 pm
Location: California, USA
MBTI Type: ENTJ

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby Ace_ » Tue Feb 15, 2011 9:35 am

There are so many INTPs who think they're INFPs. I don't know why this happens. Fi and Ti are really not even similar.
User avatar
Ace_
 
Posts: 239
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2009 12:59 pm
Location: Bosnia and Herzegovina
MBTI Type: ENTJ
Gender: Male

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby delilah » Sat Mar 05, 2011 4:48 pm

It's fully possible that he's got a weak F or a weak T.
she stained any room she spilled herself into
User avatar
delilah
 
Posts: 6
Joined: Thu Mar 03, 2011 7:28 pm
Location: toronto
MBTI Type: infp
Gender: Female

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby senada » Fri Mar 11, 2011 11:42 am

mserogerb wrote:I have a friend/relative that sometimes tests as an INFP but lately has been testing as INTP.
The IN P are all very strong but the T/F is weak. So he finds that some of the INTP profile fits and some does not and some of the INFP profile fits and some does not.

Have any of you experienced this in yourself or others?


Yes.

There's a couple of things to take note of.

First of all, on the tests, they have certain questions that are not easy to answer straightforwardly. Let's say, if a question asks "when making a decision, do you rely on your logics, or your feelings?". Well, to be honest with you, INFPs' feelings are quite personal, and so logics are incorporated into their feelings, hence you'll find them working through matters of logics before arriving at a much more personal conclusion to them, that usually takes care of values, and ethical considerations. They are probably more outwardly thinking, in that they focus more on the layout of things. Whereas INTPs, they are much more focused, in degree and length, with their thoughts and how far they can develop these thoughts (Ti), for the sake of these 'thoughts'. The difference with them and INFPs is that the INFPs' focus inwards is more in tune with developing values/ethics, and so they can spend a great deal of time in thought with or without realizing that they are nourishing a certain outlook. INTPs I guess are much more objective, thus better with handling criticisms, but they may have a distate for criticism if a comment downplays their ideas/thoughts, since they believe they have spent adequate time in analysis of a subject.

On the other hand, to move away from type functions and what not, you have to also bear in mind the fact that sometimes our hobbies, and interests, shape our persona, or behaviour. If an INFP loves puzzles, especially the challenging difficult ones, their personality will be influenced accordingly. They'll probably be more logical. My INTP best friend likes exploring "spiritual" (for lack of a better term) matters, and so has a good sense of emotions, and can even size up to them if not have the kind of interpersonal skills to be in touch with other people's emotions. My INTP friend also believes, just like an INFP would have the tendency to believe, that they are most learnt of a person's human side when one expresses their sadness/vulnerability, etc. I guess that sometimes INTPs and INFPs end up in the same place, but from different angles and approaches.
User avatar
senada
 
Posts: 51
Joined: Wed Sep 23, 2009 10:11 am
MBTI Type: xNFx
Gender: Female

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby sokko » Wed Dec 07, 2011 8:08 am

Ace_ wrote:There are so many INTPs who think they're INFPs. I don't know why this happens. Fi and Ti are really not even similar.


You mean INFPs who think they are INTPs? The opposite is not really possible and it's sort of known that only an NF could think he is an NT, not the other way around. The reason is that NTs do not have enough feelings to make them rate themselves as NFs (some exception NTs up to sing reasonably well, like John Travolta, or play an instrument reasonably well, like George Harrison, but it's reasonably clear neither one of them thinks themselves as a feeling dominant).

The feeling dominant has thinking also, it being together with his dominant feeling, though not all feeling dominants do up to any amount of thinking, but many do and are as often high educated as the NTs are, just more on the humanistic area, so it's not a question that they are not up to high thinkers, just that their areas of thinking differ, though they can have success and in school they do have success at all subjects; those people do not see it easily if they are thinking or feeling dominants and many of them think a lot, often more than many NTs, especially when the NF does it for living.
sokko
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Wed Dec 07, 2011 7:38 am
Location: Finland
MBTI Type: INTp
Gender: Male

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby lamer » Wed Dec 14, 2011 8:28 am

INFP and INTP are quite easy to be mistyped at the first place.
INFPs are pretty smart ( more on being book smart) as INTPs, especially when both are well educated. Both are very logical, quiet, big picture ( both are all intuitives). For the appearance, they have some similar things: have sorrow look and slender shape ...( like they are beaing some pain , especially INFP)
But the main thing is INFP: belongs to NF types. Hence, they are more people focus- they care more about people's feeling, whether they would hurt someone. And they are more moral oriented. Also, INFPs are more organised than the INTP.
INTP types: belongs to NT types, like many NTs- they would be considered: mad/ crazy, nuts to some people. :mrgreen:
hey, if you guys are ENTJs, you guys would regconise an INFP and find him/her pretty connected to you just by your subconcious mind- instinct. INTPs cant give you that deep connection ( just INFP share the same Fi with you, not INTP with Fe)
Per timorem ambulate! Flammam in anima ardete! Longa et obcura nox a prima luce superabitur.
lamer
 
Posts: 436
Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2010 10:19 pm
MBTI Type: ENTJ
Gender: Female

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby PoodleSyndrome » Wed Dec 14, 2011 12:21 pm

INFP - The one I know is a very nice gentle person. I get along with them. They seem quite empathic. However they are quite neurotic and sensitive, so I have to sooooo careful about what I say. They also seem to be unable unwrangle themselves in difficult situations and cannot think through their issues or problems. I read on the internet that INFPs are most likely to suffer from clinical depression and have ADHD.

INTP - I met one some time ago, but do not know this person well. The one I know has a quick grasp of situations and people. He was smart and very articulate. However he was really unreliable and naive about handling the situation well.

I can't see how people can mistake one for the other. They are quite different.
The smartest dog is .... a Border Collie.
User avatar
PoodleSyndrome
 
Posts: 119
Joined: Wed Jan 13, 2010 7:03 am
MBTI Type: ENTJ
Gender: Female

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby John_Mann » Sat May 25, 2013 6:19 pm

Fe is the shadow function of INTP's.

Psy maturity is achieved when you improve your shadow, so it's natural to a mature INTP switch to both functions (but always Ti 51%- Fe 49% in the final sum).

I can easily switch between I-E (ENTP) and T-F (INFP/ENFP) but I have a hard time in P-J.

I just can reach J in small periods of time and only in the introverse mode (INTJ).

J drains my energy like a mosquito on a leech. I have a well developed Si too (the tertiary function in INTP's), 'cause it's the main fuel of Ne.

INTP functions: 1-Ti; 2-Ne; 3-Si; 4-Fe
John_Mann
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Sat May 25, 2013 5:51 pm
MBTI Type: INTP
Gender: Male

Re: INFP vs INTP

Postby LOST TALE » Wed Jul 09, 2014 10:52 am

This is the cas eof one of my friends:


I have a friend who is INTP when introverted
and ENFP when extraverted

The Deep mind ( Intuition /sensing) focuses on intuitive material logics like us. But the Quick mind relies on logic.
Since he is P he uses the Deep Mind more, and so depending on the quick mind feelings there may be variations!

Being nailed by girls for favors ( I need to hire my other friend the rational diplomat to keep guard) I got better things to do with my empathy.

The INFP is recognised as the most inteligent of my class (because he spent time showing it off (not with the bad intonetion). but behind his mature thoughts is a feeler 8-) . But his intuition is focused on material connections, instead of diplomatic human relations... A deep Intuitive mind and the Fast mind uses feelings. An interesting mix to talk to! He lacks judgement (use of quick mind) so his logic deep brain accompaniesh feels and ..complex.

He does show sometimes the ''It's meant to be'' idealistic Bias although he brags being realist, but with the lack of understanding, has a very cynical view of society (EXTREME).
LOST TALE
 
Posts: 48
Joined: Mon Jul 07, 2014 8:05 am
MBTI Type: XNTX
Gender: Male


Return to NTs (Rationals)

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest